What is the purpose of this community consultation?

    To seek feedback from local residents, interested community members, user groups and oval users on a proposed upgrade of sports lighting at David Cruikshank Reserve, Nedlands.  

    Where is David Cruickshank Reserve located?

    David Cruikshank Reserve is located on the corner of Beatrice Road and Wattle Avenue, Nedlands.  

    Why is the City proposing to upgrade the sports lighting at David Cruikshank Reserve?

    The current infrastructure does not meet the relevant Australian Standards as the lights emit a lower level of luminance than is required for safe sporting activity. The current lights do not cover the entire oval which under-utilises the space and concentrates all the wear and tear in one area, which is detrimental to the grass. Collegians Amateur Football Club (CAFC) are seeking to upgrade the sports floodlighting to facilitate evening training.  

    What works are being proposed as part of the upgrade?

    The proposed works would involve removing the three existing poles and installing new poles with LED light fittings. Four conceptual designs have been prepared and are available for review on the Your Voice community consultation page at yourvoice.nedlands.wa.gov.au.  

    The lighting would be designed to meet the Australian Standards AS2560 (Sports Lighting) for training (50 lux) and AS4282 (Control of Obtrusive Effects of Outdoor Lighting).  

    What are the benefits?

    Upgraded sports lighting would: 

    • Meet the relevant Australian Standards and emit the safe level of luminance that is required for safe sporting activity, 

    • Taller light poles and new LED lighting technology will concentrate the light on the oval and reduce the amount of light leaving the field (light spill), 

    • The new LED lighting system would require less maintenance and be more energy efficient, 

    • Improve safety for all users of the reserve, 

    • Allow for a greater ability for local residents and community groups to use the oval at night, 

    • Allow for the development of womens football teams being able to train on the same days as the men’s teams, 

    • Allow for the entire oval to be used resulting in less wear on tear, 

    • Allow for just the pavilion side of the oval to be used allowing training to take place further away from residents, 

    • Allow for improved time management of lighting i.e. curfew time switches. 

    Similar sports lighting has been installed at Allen Park Lower Oval, Swanbourne. The photo on the YourVoice page is of similar lighting installed at Tom Perrott Reserve in Mosman Park. 

    How would the use of the proposed lighting be managed?

    The proposed sports lighting would be managed by the City in relation to approved bookings made by sporting clubs, schools, community groups and individuals, in accordance with the City’s existing hiring process.  

    When will the lights be on?

    The lights are currently used Monday to Friday 5.30pm-9.00pm (April to September). 

    The proposed lighting is not proposed to be used on any additional nights, nor beyond current timings. The new lighting control system will be able to be accessed remotely and set to switch off automatically at designated times. 

    The proposed new poles are up to 30m tall. Do they need to be this high?

    In general, taller poles result in less obtrusive light and spill as the light is directed vertically, whilst improving the light conditions to allow for evening training to occur. 

    The lights have been designed by an independent sports lighting consultant to cover the entire oval, provide the Australian Standard level of lighting, reduce light spill and allow the lights to be set back from the playing surface. 

    When would the works take place?

    If the project is supported by Council and secures grant funding, the works would take place in 2024.  

    How would the proposed lighting upgrade be funded?

    The City will seek funding support from State Government through the Club Night Lights Funding Program and the balance of funding will be covered by Collegians Amateur Football Club. The City will manage project delivery.   

    In reference to the four conceptual designs mentioned above, it should be noted that Options 3 and 4 will not meet the Australian Standard requirements for sports lighting and will not be supported by the Club, nor will be eligible for State Government funding. If options 3 or 4 are selected as the preferred option the City would need to fund the full cost of works.  

    Who is being engaged on this project?

    The City is engaging directly with the following community stakeholders: 

    • Residents and ratepayers within a 200 metre radius of David Cruikshank Reserve,  

    • representatives from David Cruikshank user groups, 

    • interested community members 

    What happens next?

    The outcomes of the community consultation will be collated and presented to Council in early 2024, along with a Club Night Lights Funding Program grant application, for Council consideration. If endorsed, the grant application will be forwarded to the Department of Local Government, Sport and Cultural Industries for consideration for grant funding.